Miscellany

Miscellany

Postby Prototype on Tue Jun 02, 2015 2:22 pm

Dear Prof,

a- Logic

I´m in two minds about the way English people use distributional properties ( mathematics) in language. eg:

A mouse has got a tail. What happens when this sentence is turned into the plural?: Mice have got a tail or Mice have got tails. I go for the former version, in my language using the latter implies that mice have got more than one tail. What about English?

Thanks a lot
Prototype
 

Re: Miscellany

Postby prof on Tue Jun 02, 2015 7:07 pm

The problem with your usage works the other way around. If you say 'mice have got a tail' the question then becomes 'who looks after that tail for the mice? Or do they take turns wearing it?'

To use a different example, if we say 'people in that jungle tribe live in a tree house' the question becomes whether the entire tribe live in the one building. However if people in that jungle tribe live in tree houses, we know that they are not a small tribe with a single big building.

So to return to the mice, if we say that 'Mice have tails' there is no problem with this because if we have say, three mice then we have three tails - the plural for 'tail' is justified. We are not saying that a mouse - singular- has tails, but where there are many mice there will be many tails.

If you do need to clear up any ambiguity, then you need to say something like 'Mice have one tail each.'
prof
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2692
Joined: Wed Dec 07, 2005 11:10 am


Return to any questions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

Privacy Policy     cron